The episode begins with Gumball chatting with Penny. Anais comes in the room and asks him what he is doing. Gumball is eating online dinner with her via emojis. Gumball then freaks out when Penny leaves, but types out one emoji with hearts for eyes instead of three. Anais tries explaining that Penny was just tired, but Gumball takes it as a sign she is losing interest in him. Determined to not let this happen, he decides to set her up a treasure hunt to remind her of the memories they have shared.